For approximately one-third of estrogen receptor (ER)-positive breast cancer patients, extracted tumor ER is unable to bind to its cognate DNA estrogen response element (ERE), an effect that is partly reversible by the thiol-reducing agent dithiothreitol (DTT). Full-length (67 kDa) ER or its 11 kDa recombinant DNA-binding domain (ER-DBD) is also susceptible to loss of structure and function by the action of oxidants such as diamide and hydrogen peroxide; however, prior DNA binding by ER or ER-DBD protects against this oxidant induced loss of function. The ER-DBD contains two (Cys)(4)-liganded zinc finger motifs that cooperate to stabilize a rigid DNA-binding recognition helix and a flexible helix-supported dimerization loop, respectively. Comparisons between synthetic peptide analogues of each zinc finger and recombinant ER-DBD in the presence of zinc by electrophoretic mobility shift assay, circular dichroism, and mass spectrometry confirm that cooperativity between these zinc fingers is required for both ER-DBD structure (alpha-helicity) and function (dimeric DNA binding). Rapid proteolytic digestion of monomeric, non-DNA-bound ER-DBD followed by HPLC-MS analysis of the resulting peptides demonstrates that zinc inhibits thiol oxidation of the DNA-binding finger, but not the finger supporting the flexible dimerization loop, which remains sensitive to internal disulfide formation. These findings indicate that the loss of ER DNA-binding function in extracts from some primary breast tumors and in ER or ER-DBD exposed to thiol-reacting oxidants results from this asymmetric zinc finger susceptibility to disulfide formation that prevents dimerization. Although ER-DBD contains several strategically located methionine residues, they are less susceptible to oxidation than the thiol groups and, thus, afford no protection against cysteine oxidation and consequent loss of ER DNA-binding function.