Continuous measurement of lactate is potentially useful for detecting physical exhaustion and for monitoring critical care conditions characterized by hypoperfusion, such as heart failure. In some conditions, it may be desirable to monitor more than one metabolic parameter concurrently. For this reason, we designed and fabricated twisted wire-based microelectrodes that can measure both lactate and glucose. These dual-analyte sensors were characterized in vitro by measuring their response to the analyte of interest and to assess whether they were susceptible to interference from the other analyte. When measured in stirred aqueous buffer, lactate sensors detected a very small amount of crosstalk from glucose in vitro, although this signal was less than 3% of the response to lactate. Glucose sensors did not detect crosstalk from lactate. Sensors were implanted subcutaneously in rats and tested during infusions of lactate and glucose. Each sensing electrode responded rapidly to changes in its analyte concentration, and there was no evidence of in vivo crosstalk. This study constitutes proof of the concept that oxidase-based, amperometric wire microsensors can detect changes in glucose and lactate during subcutaneous implantation in rats.