This study tested the hypothesis that the decreased resistance of skeletal muscles to fatigue after a period of inadequate nutrition is a consequence of the type of fatigue test employed. Rats (n = 8) were fed hypocalorically for 10 days, resulting in a 33.5 +/- 3.0% (SE) reduction in body weight. The fatigue resistance of muscles was assessed with use of isolated soleus muscles at a temperature of 25 degrees C. Fatigue resistance was determined from the decline in isometric force during a series of tetanic contractions. Two contrasting contraction protocols were devised to test the susceptibility of muscles to fatigue. One protocol was designed to require high rates of energy supply and hence force a dependence on glycolytic energy supply pathways. The second protocol required much lower rates of energy supply that could be entirely met by oxidative energy supply processes. During the high energy demand (glycolytic) protocol, the force produced by muscles from a control group of rats decreased to 78.7 +/- 0.8% (n = 12 muscles) of the initial value. Hypocaloric feeding significantly reduced the resistance of muscles to fatigue: force declined to 61.3 +/- 3.5% (n = 16 muscles) during the contraction protocol. In contrast, when fatigue was quantified using the low energy demand (oxidative) contraction protocol, the effect of nutritional status on fatigue resistance was entirely abolished. This result supports the hypothesis that resistance to fatigue is critically dependent on the fatigue test employed.