The authors describe a 10-year-old Caucasian boy who presented with abnormally low oxygen saturation values on pulse oximetry after a routine tonsillectomy. He was asymptomatic and there was no personal or family history of respiratory, cardiac, or hematologic disorders. Multiple initial investigations were completed without diagnostic yield. Eventually, hemoglobinopathy studies identified the presence of a low oxygen affinity hemoglobin variant, characterized as hemoglobin Titusville. Hemoglobinopathies remain highly prevalent worldwide, with more than 65 low oxygen affinity hemoglobin variants identified to date. Early recognition of abnormal hemoglobin variants in asymptomatic patients may avoid extensive, unnecessary medical investigations.