Objective: One possible cause of back pain in patients with intervertebral disk degeneration is decreased stability of the motion segment. Axial rotations between lumbar spinal vertebrae can be measured noninvasively with CT. We tested the hypothesis that larger axial rotations are found in motion segments with disks that test positive for concordant pain, which is considered by some investigators to be a reasonable, accurate predictor of spinal instability.
Subjects and methods: Between October 2002 and March 2004, all patients undergoing discography were evaluated for inclusion in the study, with the approval of the institutional review board. All patients in whom concordant pain was detected at discography were enrolled in the study. The patients were placed supine in the CT scanner on a table that rotated the pelvis 8 degrees clockwise and then counterclockwise with respect to the thorax. CT images were obtained with the patient in the two positions of rotation. An automated program calculated the amount of rotation between each lumbar vertebra as a result of the table rotations. Rotations were stratified by disk level and by disk classification (concordant pain, nonconcordant pain, no significant pain).
Results: We recorded the axial rotations of 94 disks in 16 consecutive patients (10 women, six men; age range, 26-53 years) after two disks were excluded because of a previous fusion. There were 68 normal disks by MRI and discography, six disks with nonconcordant pain, and 20 disks with concordant pain. Rotation averaged 0.6 degrees for the normal disks, 1.4 degrees for disks with nonconcordant pain, and 1.8 degrees for disks with concordant pain. The differences were significant (analysis of variance, p < 0.001). Disks at L3-L4 with concordant pain rotated on average 1.2 degrees , whereas disks classified as normal or nonconcordant pain rotated on average 0.7 degrees (significant at p = 0.005). Disks at L4-L5 with concordant pain rotated on average 1.9 degrees , and those without concordant pain rotated on average 1.4 degrees (significant at p = 0.05). Disks with concordant pain at L5-S1 had an average rotation of 2.2 degrees , whereas disks without concordant pain had an average rotation of 1.5 degrees (marginally significant difference at p = 0.07).
Conclusion: Concordant pain at discography predicts increased axial rotation at a lumbar disk level.