Autotransplants in leukemia are controversial; their rationale and results have been questioned. Here we consider several issues central to this debate: (1) Are there convincing data to suggest that more intensive therapy increases cures? (2) Are results post-autotransplant a consequence of the transplant, or do they reflect subject-selection and time-to-treatment (time censoring) biases? (3) Does leukemia relapse after an autotransplant develop from persisting leukemia cells in the subject or the graft? (4) Do autotransplants using hematopoietic stem cells from different sources have distinct outcomes? (5) Are immune-mediated anti-leukemia mechanisms likely to prevent relapse after autotransplants? and (6) Can comparably intensive therapy be given without an autotransplant?