Objective: To determine whether the heart rate changes during tilt table testing could be used in the differential diagnosis between vasovagal syncope and chronic autonomic failure.
Methods: We compared the relationship between electrocardiographic R-R intervals and beat-to-beat blood pressure in 43 patients with typical vasovagal responses and 30 patients with chronic autonomic failure (6 pure autonomic failure, 23 multiple system atrophy, and 1 Parkinson's disease).
Results: In every patient with vasovagal syncope, at the time when the blood pressure was falling, it was possible to identify at least 12 successive heart beats (mean 33 +/- 2 heart beat, range 12-57) when blood pressure and heart rate fell in parallel, i.e., there was a negative relationship between blood pressure and R-R intervals (P < 0.001). In contrast, the relationship between blood pressure and R-R intervals in patients with chronic autonomic failure was never negative, i.e., heart rate always increased, albeit less than expected for the given fall in blood pressure, or remained unchanged.
Interpretation: The heart rate changes during the fall in blood pressure can distinguish patients with vasovagal responses from those with chronic autonomic failure.