Colorectal cancer patients with isolated liver metastasis are potentially cured with surgical resection. Recent advances in systemic chemotherapy have increased the ability to convert unresectable metastatic liver lesions to resectable lesions. The cost in toxicity of these therapeutic advances is increasingly being recognized. Numerous reports have demonstrated an association between irinotecan and steatohepatitis as well as between oxaliplatin and sinusoidal dilation. In this review, we summarize the current clinical experience with these hepatic toxicities and discuss the role they play in determining postoperative morbidity. We also review emerging safety data regarding the use of bevacizumab and cetuximab. Finally, we give specific clinical examples of how multidisciplinary teams can best manage patients receiving preoperative chemotherapy for potentially resectable liver metastases.