Liver failure in newborns can present formidable diagnostic challenges. The presentation of neonatal liver failure is variable and the initial assessment is crucial in the determination of potentially treatable causes. We present a case of neonatal hemochromatosis, review genetic and metabolic causes of neonatal liver failure, and outline an updated differential diagnosis of neonatal liver failure. In addition, we propose a comprehensive initial work-up of neonatal liver failure, and review current treatments for neonatal hemochromatosis.