Maximal degree of airway narrowing induced by methacholine and adenosine monophosphate: relationship with the decrease in forced vital capacity

Background: Changes in forced vital capacity (FVC) may represent an indirect method for the detection of plateau in response to inhaled bronchoconstrictor agents.

Objective: To determine the relationship between the level of plateau obtained with either methacholine or adenosine monophosphate (AMP) and the decrease in FVC induced by each bronchoconstrictor agent.

Methods: Airway responsiveness to high concentrations of methacholine and AMP was determined in patients with intermittent asthma (n = 41) or allergic rhinitis (n = 26). Furthermore, allergen-induced changes in the response to each bronchoconstrictor agent were investigated in 18 pollen-sensitive patients. Concentration-response curves were characterized by the slope of the FVC values recorded at each step of the challenge against the corresponding forced expiratory volume in 1 second (FEV1) values and, if possible, by the level of plateau.

Results: The slope FVC vs FEV1 was similar in patients with plateau and in those without plateau. In patients with pollen allergy, the mean (95% confidence interval) for the level of plateau detected with methacholine increased from 16.8% (11.8%-22.0%) before the pollen season to 21.7% (14.8%-28.6%, P = .008) during the pollen season, whereas pollen-induced changes in the slope FVC vs FEV1 were not significant. Similar results were obtained with AMP.

Conclusions: In patients with allergic rhinitis or intermittent asthma, methacholine or AMP-induced changes in FVC are not significantly related to the presence or level of plateau. Furthermore, these 2 constituents of the concentration-response curve can be modified independently by a proinflammatory stimulus. These results suggest that the bronchoconstrictor-induced change in FVC cannot be used as a surrogate estimation of the level of plateau.