Different designs for producing multiple stopband mesoporous silicon rugate filters via electrochemical anodization are compared. The effects of light absorption and dispersion to visible range filter design are investigated. Thermal oxidation is applied for passivating the chemically reactive porous silicon surface, and the response of the passivated structures to ethanol vapor is examined. Differences in gas sensing properties for the various designs are evaluated and possible reasons for the observed differences are discussed. Methods for sidelobe suppression in multipeak filters are discussed and demonstrated, and their effects in gas sensing applications are estimated.