In the absence of an effective vaccine against the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV), topical microbicides to prevent the sexual transmission of HIV represent an important strategy to prevent the continued spread of infection. The recent trend in the development of new microbicide candidates includes the utilization of FDA-approved therapeutic drugs that target the early stages of the HIV life cycle, including entry inhibitors and reverse transcriptase inhibitors. We have investigated 12 pyrimidinedione compounds with potent HIV activities and their abilities to inhibit both virus entry and reverse transcription, in an effort to determine a lead microbicide for product development. The candidate compounds were evaluated for efficacy against subtype B, C, and E clinical virus strains in fresh human peripheral blood mononuclear cells and against CCR5-tropic virus strains in both monocyte-macrophages and dendritic cells. Microbicide-specific biological assays and toxicity evaluations were also performed in a variety of established and fresh human cells as well as against Lactobacillus strains common to the vaginal environment. These evaluations resulted in the identification of congeners with cyclopropyl and cyclobutyl substituents at the N-1 of the pyrimidinedione as the most active molecules in the structure-activity relationship series. The pyrimidinediones represent excellent microbicide candidates in light of their significantly high efficacies against HIV-1 (subnanomolar concentration range), potencies (therapeutic index, >1 million), solubility profiles, and dual mechanism of antiviral action that includes two early steps of virus replication prior to the integration of the virus that are considered most important for microbicidal activity.