The cut off for hemoglobin or hematocrit that indicates the need for an isotopic red cell mass study was investigated in 179 patients with a presumptive diagnosis of polycythemia vera or essential thrombocythemia. Hematocrit showed better diagnostic accuracy than hemoglobin. Hemoglobin over 18.5 g/dL in males or over 16.5 g/dL in females showed a high specificity indicating that red cell mass study could be avoided in such cases, but it showed low sensitivity leading to 46% false negatives. The best value of hematocrit to indicate a red cell mass study was 0.50 L/L in males (specificity 75%, sensitivity 87.5%) and 0.48 L/L in females (specificity 73%, sensitivity 94%). Lowering the hematocrit threshold to 0.48 L/L in males increased sensitivity up to 95%. A red cell mass study should be performed in patients with suspected diagnosis of essential thrombocythemia or polycythemia vera and with hematocrit between 0.48 L/L and 0.52 L/L.