Myocardial infarction (MI) causes significant cell loss and damage to myocardium. Cell-based therapies for treatment of MI aim to remuscularize the resultant scar tissue, but the majority of transplanted cells do not survive or integrate with the host tissue. Scaffolds can improve cell retention following construct implantation, but often do little to enhance host-graft integration and/or show limited biodegradation. Fibrin is an ideal biomaterial for cardiac tissue engineering as it is a natural, biodegradable polymer that can induce neovascularization, promote cell attachment, and has tunable mechanical properties. Here we describe a novel, high-density microtemplated fibrin scaffold seeded with a tri-cell mixture of cardiomyocytes, endothelial cells (ECs), and fibroblasts to mimic native cardiac tissue in structure and cellular composition to improve cell retention and promote integration with the host tissue. Scaffolds were designed with uniform architecture of parallel 60 μm microchannels surrounded by an interconnected microporous network of 27-μm-diameter pores and mechanical stiffness comparable to native cardiac tissues (70-90kPa). Scaffold degradation was controlled with the addition of Factor XIII (FXIII) and/or protease inhibitor (aprotinin). Unmodified scaffolds had a fast degradation profile both in vitro (19.9%±3.9% stiffness retention after 10 days) and in vivo. Scaffolds treated with FXIII showed an intermediate degradation profile in vitro (45.8%±5.9%), while scaffolds treated with aprotinin or both FXIII and aprotinin showed significantly slowed degradation in vitro (60.9%±5.2% and 76.4%±7.6%, respectively, p<0.05). Acellular aprotinin scaffold myocardial implants showed decreased collagen deposition after 7 days. Unmodified and aprotinin implants could not be located by 14 days, while 2 of 8 FXIII implants were found, but were significantly degraded. Constructs supported seeded cell survival and organization in vitro, promoting EC-lined lumen structure formation in construct channels and colocalization of viable ECs and cardiomyocytes. In addition, constructs promoted extracellular matrix deposition by seeded cells, as shown by collagen staining within construct channels and by significant increases in construct stiffness over 10 days in vitro (209%±32%, p<0.05). The data suggest our fibrin scaffolds are ideally designed to promote graft cell survival and organization, thus improving chances of promoting construct integration with the host tissue upon implantation.