Thorotrast: analysis of the time evolution of its α activity concentration, in the 70 years following the chemical purification of Thorium

Phys Med. 2013 Sep;29(5):520-30. doi: 10.1016/j.ejmp.2012.12.003. Epub 2013 Jan 18.

Abstract

We simulate the α-activity of the Thorium series elements present in the contrast medium named Thorotrast, used until 1960 and cause of certified deaths until today. Assuming, as active components at t=0, (232)Th and (228)Th in the same relative concentration they have in nature, α-activity oscillates for some decades before reaching a stationary value that in absence of biological depletion would be AST =24000Bq/g. Our Montecarlo code generates the nuclear decays of the Thorium series with and without in-vivo biological depletion, arriving to three kinds of results for the activity: 1) Theoretical activity concentration (no biological depletion). Our result is fitted by: A(t)=A(ST).{[1-exp(-t/10)]+[exp(-t/tB)(1-0.8exp(-t/tA))]}, with t in years, tA=1.07.10(-2) years, and tB=2.38 years. 2) Weak biological depletion (228Ra/232 Th equilibrium activity ratio 0.6, 224Ra/228Ra e.a.r 0.9, 10% excretion for 220Rn). The ratio of the activity concentration to the theoretical activity concentration is fitted by: A weak (t)/A(t)=0.61+0.29 exp[-(t/15)2] (t in years). 3) Strong biological depletion (228Ra/232Th e.a.r 0.4, 224Ra/228Ra e.a.r. 0.8, 10% excretion for 220Rn). The ratio of the activity concentration to the theoretical activity concentration is fitted by A(strong)(t)/A(t)=0.44+0.4 exp[-(t/13)2](t in years). We also report fluctuation calculation for two cases where standard statistical behavior is not expected.

Keywords: Analytical fit; Monte Carlo simulation; Thorium series activity; Thorotrast.

MeSH terms

  • Alpha Particles*
  • Models, Theoretical
  • Radiochemistry
  • Thorium / chemistry*
  • Thorium / isolation & purification
  • Thorium Dioxide / chemistry
  • Time Factors

Substances

  • Thorium
  • Thorium Dioxide