Video-assisted thoracic surgery for bronchogenic cysts: is this the surgical approach of choice?

Objectives: Although there is no consensus on the management of bronchogenic cyst, most surgeons advocate early removal, even in asymptomatic patients. To evaluate the feasibility and safety of video-assisted thoracic surgery (VATS) in the management of bronchogenic cysts and long-term follow-up, a retrospective analysis was performed.

Methods: From January 1995 to April 2013, we retrospectively reviewed the charts of 113 patients who underwent VATS resection of bronchogenic cysts in our institution. Resection of the bronchogenic cysts by VATS was initially performed in patients who had a cyst in the thoracic cavity and no evidence of severely dense adhesion to other organs or tissues on a CT scan. Also, patients with a history of previous thoracic surgeries, in addition to those with concomitant diseases requiring surgical treatment, were enrolled in our series. Operations were carried out using the conventional three-port technique and histological examinations confirmed the diagnosis of benign bronchogenic cyst containing a ciliated columnar epithelial lining.

Results: The median size of the cysts was 3.7 cm in their greatest diameter (range, 1-10 cm). One hundred and nine patients with bronchogenic cyst were resected completely by VATS. In 4 cases, VATS was converted to open thoracotomy or median sternotomy: major adhesion to the bronchus in 2, left innominate venous injury in 1 and repair of bronchial tear by surgery in 1. We identified 5 intraoperative complications of tracheobronchial tear, vascular injury and oesophageal laceration. The median operation time was 96.8 min (range, 15-320 min). There were no operative mortalities or major postoperative complications. Patients with VATS excision were discharged after a median of 3.7 days postoperatively. The long-term follow-up ranged from 1 to 11 years, with a median follow-up of 4.2 years. There were no late complications or recurrences.

Conclusions: Considering the low conversion and complication rate, VATS was safe and effective in the resection of the bronchogenic cysts. The size and the location of cysts were not important considerations in selecting the surgical method. VATS excision should be considered the primary therapeutic option in the management of patients with bronchogenic cysts.