This case report illustrates the importance of proper assessment, management, and creation of an emergent surgical airway. Assessment after the establishment of surgical airways should include confirmation of correct surgical site and appropriate location and depth of tracheostomy, tracheal tube, or catheter placement within the trachea. Supraglottic surgical airway access, as occurred in this case, can lead to laryngotracheal and esophageal injury. Early recognition and appropriate management of this complication can increase the likelihood of preservation of voice and airway function and minimize the extent of esophageal injury.