Inference of domestication history and differentiation between early- and late-flowering varieties in pearl millet

Mol Ecol. 2015 Apr;24(7):1387-402. doi: 10.1111/mec.13119. Epub 2015 Mar 20.

Abstract

Pearl millet (Pennisetum glaucum) is a staple crop in Sahelian Africa. Farmers usually grow varieties with different cycle lengths and complementary functions in Sahelian agrosystems. Both the level of genetic differentiation of these varieties and the domestication history of pearl millet have been poorly studied. We investigated the neutral genetic diversity and population genetic structure of early- and late-flowering domesticated and wild pearl millet populations using 18 microsatellite loci and 8 nucleotide sequences. Strikingly, early- and late-flowering domesticated varieties were not differentiated over their whole distribution area, despite a clear difference in their isolation-by-distance pattern. Conversely, our data brought evidence for two well-differentiated genetic pools in wild pearl millet, allowing us to test scenarios with different numbers and origins of domestication using approximate Bayesian computation (ABC). The ABC analysis showed the likely existence of asymmetric migration between wild and domesticated populations. The model choice procedure indicated that a single domestication from the eastern wild populations was the more likely scenario to explain the polymorphism patterns observed in cultivated pearl millet.

Keywords: approximate Bayesian computation; asymmetric gene flow; cycle length; domestication history; pearl millet.

Publication types

  • Research Support, Non-U.S. Gov't

MeSH terms

  • Computer Simulation
  • Crops, Agricultural / genetics
  • Crops, Agricultural / growth & development
  • DNA, Plant / genetics
  • Evolution, Molecular*
  • Flowers / growth & development*
  • Genetic Variation*
  • Genetics, Population*
  • Microsatellite Repeats
  • Models, Genetic
  • Molecular Sequence Data
  • Pennisetum / genetics*
  • Pennisetum / growth & development
  • Sequence Tagged Sites

Substances

  • DNA, Plant

Associated data

  • Dryad/10.5061/dryad.22QC2
  • GENBANK/KP788035
  • GENBANK/KP788036
  • GENBANK/KP788037
  • GENBANK/KP788038
  • GENBANK/KP788039
  • GENBANK/KP788040
  • GENBANK/KP788041
  • GENBANK/KP788042
  • GENBANK/KP788043
  • GENBANK/KP788044
  • GENBANK/KP788045
  • GENBANK/KP788046
  • GENBANK/KP788047
  • GENBANK/KP788048
  • GENBANK/KP788049
  • GENBANK/KP788050
  • GENBANK/KP788051
  • GENBANK/KP788052
  • GENBANK/KP788053
  • GENBANK/KP788054
  • GENBANK/KP788055
  • GENBANK/KP788056
  • GENBANK/KP788057
  • GENBANK/KP788058
  • GENBANK/KP788059
  • GENBANK/KP788060
  • GENBANK/KP788061
  • GENBANK/KP788062
  • GENBANK/KP788063
  • GENBANK/KP788064
  • GENBANK/KP788065
  • GENBANK/KP788066
  • GENBANK/KP788067
  • GENBANK/KP788068
  • GENBANK/KP788069
  • GENBANK/KP788070
  • GENBANK/KP788071
  • GENBANK/KP788072
  • GENBANK/KP788073
  • GENBANK/KP788074
  • GENBANK/KP788075
  • GENBANK/KP788076
  • GENBANK/KP788077
  • GENBANK/KP788078
  • GENBANK/KP788079
  • GENBANK/KP788080
  • GENBANK/KP788081
  • GENBANK/KP788082
  • GENBANK/KP788083
  • GENBANK/KP788084
  • GENBANK/KP788085
  • GENBANK/KP788086
  • GENBANK/KP788087
  • GENBANK/KP788088
  • GENBANK/KP788089
  • GENBANK/KP788090
  • GENBANK/KP788091
  • GENBANK/KP788092
  • GENBANK/KP788093
  • GENBANK/KP788094
  • GENBANK/KP788095
  • GENBANK/KP788096
  • GENBANK/KP788097
  • GENBANK/KP788098
  • GENBANK/KP788099
  • GENBANK/KP788100
  • GENBANK/KP788101
  • GENBANK/KP788102
  • GENBANK/KP788103
  • GENBANK/KP788104
  • GENBANK/KP788105
  • GENBANK/KP788106
  • GENBANK/KP788107
  • GENBANK/KP788108
  • GENBANK/KP788109
  • GENBANK/KP788110
  • GENBANK/KP788111
  • GENBANK/KP788112
  • GENBANK/KP788113
  • GENBANK/KP788114
  • GENBANK/KP788115
  • GENBANK/KP788116
  • GENBANK/KP788117
  • GENBANK/KP788118
  • GENBANK/KP788119
  • GENBANK/KP788120
  • GENBANK/KP788121
  • GENBANK/KP788122
  • GENBANK/KP788123
  • GENBANK/KP788124
  • GENBANK/KP788125
  • GENBANK/KP788126
  • GENBANK/KP788127
  • GENBANK/KP788128
  • GENBANK/KP788129
  • GENBANK/KP788130
  • GENBANK/KP788131
  • GENBANK/KP788132
  • GENBANK/KP788133
  • GENBANK/KP788134
  • GENBANK/KP788135
  • GENBANK/KP788136
  • GENBANK/KP788137
  • GENBANK/KP788138
  • GENBANK/KP788139
  • GENBANK/KP788140
  • GENBANK/KP788141
  • GENBANK/KP788142
  • GENBANK/KP788143
  • GENBANK/KP788144
  • GENBANK/KP788145
  • GENBANK/KP788146
  • GENBANK/KP788147
  • GENBANK/KP788148
  • GENBANK/KP788149
  • GENBANK/KP788150
  • GENBANK/KP788151
  • GENBANK/KP788152
  • GENBANK/KP788153
  • GENBANK/KP788154
  • GENBANK/KP788155
  • GENBANK/KP788156
  • GENBANK/KP788157
  • GENBANK/KP788158
  • GENBANK/KP788159
  • GENBANK/KP788160
  • GENBANK/KP788161
  • GENBANK/KP788162
  • GENBANK/KP788163
  • GENBANK/KP788164
  • GENBANK/KP788165
  • GENBANK/KP788166
  • GENBANK/KP788167
  • GENBANK/KP788168
  • GENBANK/KP788169
  • GENBANK/KP788170
  • GENBANK/KP788171
  • GENBANK/KP788172
  • GENBANK/KP788173
  • GENBANK/KP788174
  • GENBANK/KP788175
  • GENBANK/KP788176
  • GENBANK/KP788177
  • GENBANK/KP788178
  • GENBANK/KP788179
  • GENBANK/KP788180
  • GENBANK/KP788181
  • GENBANK/KP788182
  • GENBANK/KP788183
  • GENBANK/KP788184
  • GENBANK/KP788185
  • GENBANK/KP788186
  • GENBANK/KP788187
  • GENBANK/KP788188
  • GENBANK/KP788189
  • GENBANK/KP788190
  • GENBANK/KP788191
  • GENBANK/KP788192
  • GENBANK/KP788193
  • GENBANK/KP788194
  • GENBANK/KP788195
  • GENBANK/KP788196
  • GENBANK/KP788197
  • GENBANK/KP788198
  • GENBANK/KP788199
  • GENBANK/KP788200
  • GENBANK/KP788201
  • GENBANK/KP788202
  • GENBANK/KP788203
  • GENBANK/KP788204
  • GENBANK/KP788205
  • GENBANK/KP788206
  • GENBANK/KP788207
  • GENBANK/KP788208
  • GENBANK/KP788209
  • GENBANK/KP788210
  • GENBANK/KP788211
  • GENBANK/KP788212
  • GENBANK/KP788213
  • GENBANK/KP788214
  • GENBANK/KP788215
  • GENBANK/KP788216
  • GENBANK/KP788217
  • GENBANK/KP788218
  • GENBANK/KP788219
  • GENBANK/KP788220
  • GENBANK/KP788221
  • GENBANK/KP788222
  • GENBANK/KP788223
  • GENBANK/KP788224
  • GENBANK/KP788225
  • GENBANK/KP788226
  • GENBANK/KP788227
  • GENBANK/KP788228
  • GENBANK/KP788229
  • GENBANK/KP788230
  • GENBANK/KP788231
  • GENBANK/KP788232
  • GENBANK/KP788233
  • GENBANK/KP788234
  • GENBANK/KP788235
  • GENBANK/KP788236
  • GENBANK/KP788237
  • GENBANK/KP788238
  • GENBANK/KP788239
  • GENBANK/KP788240
  • GENBANK/KP788241
  • GENBANK/KP788242
  • GENBANK/KP788243
  • GENBANK/KP788244
  • GENBANK/KP788245
  • GENBANK/KP788246
  • GENBANK/KP788247
  • GENBANK/KP788248
  • GENBANK/KP788249
  • GENBANK/KP788250
  • GENBANK/KP788251
  • GENBANK/KP788252
  • GENBANK/KP788253
  • GENBANK/KP788254
  • GENBANK/KP788255
  • GENBANK/KP788256
  • GENBANK/KP788257
  • GENBANK/KP788258
  • GENBANK/KP788259
  • GENBANK/KP788260
  • GENBANK/KP788261
  • GENBANK/KP788262
  • GENBANK/KP788263
  • GENBANK/KP788264
  • GENBANK/KP788265
  • GENBANK/KP788266
  • GENBANK/KP788267
  • GENBANK/KP788268
  • GENBANK/KP788269
  • GENBANK/KP788270
  • GENBANK/KP788271
  • GENBANK/KP788272
  • GENBANK/KP788273
  • GENBANK/KP788274
  • GENBANK/KP788275
  • GENBANK/KP788276
  • GENBANK/KP788277
  • GENBANK/KP788278
  • GENBANK/KP788279
  • GENBANK/KP788280
  • GENBANK/KP788281
  • GENBANK/KP788282
  • GENBANK/KP788283
  • GENBANK/KP788284
  • GENBANK/KP788285
  • GENBANK/KP788286
  • GENBANK/KP788287
  • GENBANK/KP788288
  • GENBANK/KP788289
  • GENBANK/KP788290
  • GENBANK/KP788291
  • GENBANK/KP788292
  • GENBANK/KP788293
  • GENBANK/KP788294
  • GENBANK/KP788295
  • GENBANK/KP788296
  • GENBANK/KP788297
  • GENBANK/KP788298
  • GENBANK/KP788299
  • GENBANK/KP788300
  • GENBANK/KP788301
  • GENBANK/KP788302
  • GENBANK/KP788303
  • GENBANK/KP788304
  • GENBANK/KP788305
  • GENBANK/KP788306
  • GENBANK/KP788307
  • GENBANK/KP788308
  • GENBANK/KP788309
  • GENBANK/KP788310
  • GENBANK/KP788311
  • GENBANK/KP788312
  • GENBANK/KP788313
  • GENBANK/KP788314
  • GENBANK/KP788315
  • GENBANK/KP788316
  • GENBANK/KP788317
  • GENBANK/KP788318
  • GENBANK/KP788319
  • GENBANK/KP788320
  • GENBANK/KP788321
  • GENBANK/KP788322
  • GENBANK/KP788323
  • GENBANK/KP788324
  • GENBANK/KP788325
  • GENBANK/KP788326
  • GENBANK/KP788327
  • GENBANK/KP788328
  • GENBANK/KP788329
  • GENBANK/KP788330
  • GENBANK/KP788331
  • GENBANK/KP788332
  • GENBANK/KP788333
  • GENBANK/KP788334
  • GENBANK/KP788335
  • GENBANK/KP788336
  • GENBANK/KP788337
  • GENBANK/KP788338
  • GENBANK/KP788339
  • GENBANK/KP788340
  • GENBANK/KP788341
  • GENBANK/KP788342
  • GENBANK/KP788343
  • GENBANK/KP788344
  • GENBANK/KP788345
  • GENBANK/KP788346
  • GENBANK/KP788347
  • GENBANK/KP788348
  • GENBANK/KP788349
  • GENBANK/KP788350
  • GENBANK/KP788351
  • GENBANK/KP788352
  • GENBANK/KP788353
  • GENBANK/KP788354
  • GENBANK/KP788355
  • GENBANK/KP788356
  • GENBANK/KP788357
  • GENBANK/KP788358
  • GENBANK/KP788359
  • GENBANK/KP788360
  • GENBANK/KP788361
  • GENBANK/KP788362
  • GENBANK/KP788363
  • GENBANK/KP788364
  • GENBANK/KP788365
  • GENBANK/KP788366
  • GENBANK/KP788367
  • GENBANK/KP788368
  • GENBANK/KP788369
  • GENBANK/KP788370
  • GENBANK/KP788371
  • GENBANK/KP788372
  • GENBANK/KP788373
  • GENBANK/KP788374
  • GENBANK/KP788375
  • GENBANK/KP788376
  • GENBANK/KP788377
  • GENBANK/KP788378
  • GENBANK/KP788379
  • GENBANK/KP788380
  • GENBANK/KP788381
  • GENBANK/KP788382
  • GENBANK/KP788383
  • GENBANK/KP788384
  • GENBANK/KP788385
  • GENBANK/KP788386
  • GENBANK/KP788387
  • GENBANK/KP788388
  • GENBANK/KP788389
  • GENBANK/KP788390
  • GENBANK/KP788391
  • GENBANK/KP788392
  • GENBANK/KP788393
  • GENBANK/KP788394
  • GENBANK/KP788395
  • GENBANK/KP788396
  • GENBANK/KP788397
  • GENBANK/KP788398
  • GENBANK/KP788399
  • GENBANK/KP788400
  • GENBANK/KP788401
  • GENBANK/KP788402
  • GENBANK/KP788403
  • GENBANK/KP788404
  • GENBANK/KP788405
  • GENBANK/KP788406
  • GENBANK/KP788407
  • GENBANK/KP788408
  • GENBANK/KP788409
  • GENBANK/KP788410
  • GENBANK/KP788411
  • GENBANK/KP788412
  • GENBANK/KP788413
  • GENBANK/KP788414
  • GENBANK/KP788415
  • GENBANK/KP788416
  • GENBANK/KP788417
  • GENBANK/KP788418
  • GENBANK/KP788419
  • GENBANK/KP788420
  • GENBANK/KP788421
  • GENBANK/KP788422
  • GENBANK/KP788423
  • GENBANK/KP788424
  • GENBANK/KP788425
  • GENBANK/KP788426
  • GENBANK/KP788427
  • GENBANK/KP788428
  • GENBANK/KP788429
  • GENBANK/KP788430
  • GENBANK/KP788431
  • GENBANK/KP788432
  • GENBANK/KP788433
  • GENBANK/KP788434
  • GENBANK/KP788435
  • GENBANK/KP788436
  • GENBANK/KP788437
  • GENBANK/KP788438
  • GENBANK/KP788439
  • GENBANK/KP788440
  • GENBANK/KP788441
  • GENBANK/KP788442
  • GENBANK/KP788443
  • GENBANK/KP788444
  • GENBANK/KP788445
  • GENBANK/KP788446
  • GENBANK/KP788447
  • GENBANK/KP788448
  • GENBANK/KP788449
  • GENBANK/KP788450
  • GENBANK/KP788451
  • GENBANK/KP788452
  • GENBANK/KP788453
  • GENBANK/KP788454
  • GENBANK/KP788455
  • GENBANK/KP788456
  • GENBANK/KP788457
  • GENBANK/KP788458
  • GENBANK/KP788459
  • GENBANK/KP788460
  • GENBANK/KP788461
  • GENBANK/KP788462
  • GENBANK/KP788463
  • GENBANK/KP788464
  • GENBANK/KP788465
  • GENBANK/KP788466
  • GENBANK/KP788467
  • GENBANK/KP788468
  • GENBANK/KP788469
  • GENBANK/KP788470
  • GENBANK/KP788471
  • GENBANK/KP788472
  • GENBANK/KP788473
  • GENBANK/KP788474
  • GENBANK/KP788475
  • GENBANK/KP788476
  • GENBANK/KP788477
  • GENBANK/KP788478
  • GENBANK/KP788479
  • GENBANK/KP788480
  • GENBANK/KP788481
  • GENBANK/KP788482
  • GENBANK/KP788483
  • GENBANK/KP788484
  • GENBANK/KP788485
  • GENBANK/KP788486
  • GENBANK/KP788487
  • GENBANK/KP788488
  • GENBANK/KP788489
  • GENBANK/KP788490
  • GENBANK/KP788491
  • GENBANK/KP788492
  • GENBANK/KP788493
  • GENBANK/KP788494
  • GENBANK/KP788495
  • GENBANK/KP788496
  • GENBANK/KP788497
  • GENBANK/KP788498
  • GENBANK/KP788499
  • GENBANK/KP788500
  • GENBANK/KP788501
  • GENBANK/KP788502
  • GENBANK/KP788503
  • GENBANK/KP788504
  • GENBANK/KP788505
  • GENBANK/KP788506
  • GENBANK/KP788507
  • GENBANK/KP788508
  • GENBANK/KP788509
  • GENBANK/KP788510
  • GENBANK/KP788511
  • GENBANK/KP788512
  • GENBANK/KP788513
  • GENBANK/KP788514
  • GENBANK/KP788515
  • GENBANK/KP788516
  • GENBANK/KP788517
  • GENBANK/KP788518
  • GENBANK/KP788519
  • GENBANK/KP788520
  • GENBANK/KP788521
  • GENBANK/KP788522
  • GENBANK/KP788523
  • GENBANK/KP788524
  • GENBANK/KP788525
  • GENBANK/KP788526
  • GENBANK/KP788527
  • GENBANK/KP788528
  • GENBANK/KP788529
  • GENBANK/KP788530
  • GENBANK/KP788531
  • GENBANK/KP788532
  • GENBANK/KP788533
  • GENBANK/KP788534
  • GENBANK/KP788535
  • GENBANK/KP788536
  • GENBANK/KP788537
  • GENBANK/KP788538
  • GENBANK/KP788539
  • GENBANK/KP788540
  • GENBANK/KP788541
  • GENBANK/KP788542
  • GENBANK/KP788543
  • GENBANK/KP788544
  • GENBANK/KP788545
  • GENBANK/KP788546
  • GENBANK/KP788547
  • GENBANK/KP788548
  • GENBANK/KP788549
  • GENBANK/KP788550
  • GENBANK/KP788551
  • GENBANK/KP788552
  • GENBANK/KP788553
  • GENBANK/KP788554
  • GENBANK/KP788555
  • GENBANK/KP788556
  • GENBANK/KP788557
  • GENBANK/KP788558
  • GENBANK/KP788559
  • GENBANK/KP788560
  • GENBANK/KP788561
  • GENBANK/KP788562
  • GENBANK/KP788563
  • GENBANK/KP788564
  • GENBANK/KP788565
  • GENBANK/KP788566
  • GENBANK/KP788567
  • GENBANK/KP788568
  • GENBANK/KP788569
  • GENBANK/KP788570
  • GENBANK/KP788571
  • GENBANK/KP788572
  • GENBANK/KP788573
  • GENBANK/KP788574
  • GENBANK/KP788575
  • GENBANK/KP788576
  • GENBANK/KP788577
  • GENBANK/KP788578
  • GENBANK/KP788579
  • GENBANK/KP788580
  • GENBANK/KP788581
  • GENBANK/KP788582
  • GENBANK/KP788583
  • GENBANK/KP788584
  • GENBANK/KP788585
  • GENBANK/KP788586
  • GENBANK/KP788587
  • GENBANK/KP788588
  • GENBANK/KP788589
  • GENBANK/KP788590
  • GENBANK/KP788591
  • GENBANK/KP788592
  • GENBANK/KP788593
  • GENBANK/KP788594
  • GENBANK/KP788595
  • GENBANK/KP788596
  • GENBANK/KP788597
  • GENBANK/KP788598
  • GENBANK/KP788599
  • GENBANK/KP788600
  • GENBANK/KP788601
  • GENBANK/KP788602
  • GENBANK/KP788603
  • GENBANK/KP788604
  • GENBANK/KP788605
  • GENBANK/KP788606
  • GENBANK/KP788607
  • GENBANK/KP788608
  • GENBANK/KP788609
  • GENBANK/KP788610
  • GENBANK/KP788611
  • GENBANK/KP788612
  • GENBANK/KP788613
  • GENBANK/KP788614
  • GENBANK/KP788615
  • GENBANK/KP788616
  • GENBANK/KP788617
  • GENBANK/KP788618
  • GENBANK/KP788619
  • GENBANK/KP788620
  • GENBANK/KP788621
  • GENBANK/KP788622
  • GENBANK/KP788623
  • GENBANK/KP788624
  • GENBANK/KP788625
  • GENBANK/KP788626
  • GENBANK/KP788627
  • GENBANK/KP788628
  • GENBANK/KP788629
  • GENBANK/KP788630
  • GENBANK/KP788631
  • GENBANK/KP788632
  • GENBANK/KP788633
  • GENBANK/KP788634
  • GENBANK/KP788635
  • GENBANK/KP788636
  • GENBANK/KP788637
  • GENBANK/KP788638
  • GENBANK/KP788639
  • GENBANK/KP788640
  • GENBANK/KP788641
  • GENBANK/KP788642
  • GENBANK/KP788643
  • GENBANK/KP788644
  • GENBANK/KP788645
  • GENBANK/KP788646
  • GENBANK/KP788647
  • GENBANK/KP788648
  • GENBANK/KP788649
  • GENBANK/KP788650
  • GENBANK/KP788651
  • GENBANK/KP788652
  • GENBANK/KP788653
  • GENBANK/KP788654
  • GENBANK/KP788655
  • GENBANK/KP788656
  • GENBANK/KP788657
  • GENBANK/KP788658
  • GENBANK/KP788659
  • GENBANK/KP788660
  • GENBANK/KP788661
  • GENBANK/KP788662
  • GENBANK/KP788663
  • GENBANK/KP788664
  • GENBANK/KP788665
  • GENBANK/KP788666
  • GENBANK/KP788667
  • GENBANK/KP788668
  • GENBANK/KP788669
  • GENBANK/KP788670
  • GENBANK/KP788671
  • GENBANK/KP788672
  • GENBANK/KP788673
  • GENBANK/KP788674
  • GENBANK/KP788675
  • GENBANK/KP788676
  • GENBANK/KP788677
  • GENBANK/KP788678
  • GENBANK/KP788679
  • GENBANK/KP788680
  • GENBANK/KP788681
  • GENBANK/KP788682
  • GENBANK/KP788683
  • GENBANK/KP788684
  • GENBANK/KP788685
  • GENBANK/KP788686
  • GENBANK/KP788687
  • GENBANK/KP788688
  • GENBANK/KP788689
  • GENBANK/KP788690
  • GENBANK/KP788691
  • GENBANK/KP788692
  • GENBANK/KP788693
  • GENBANK/KP788694
  • GENBANK/KP788695
  • GENBANK/KP788696
  • GENBANK/KP788697
  • GENBANK/KP788698
  • GENBANK/KP788699
  • GENBANK/KP788700
  • GENBANK/KP788701
  • GENBANK/KP788702
  • GENBANK/KP788703
  • GENBANK/KP788704
  • GENBANK/KP788705
  • GENBANK/KP788706
  • GENBANK/KP788707
  • GENBANK/KP788708
  • GENBANK/KP788709
  • GENBANK/KP788710
  • GENBANK/KP788711
  • GENBANK/KP788712
  • GENBANK/KP788713
  • GENBANK/KP788714