Background: Published appropriate use criteria (AUC) for Mohs micrographic surgery (MMS) for melanoma are based on consensus opinion.
Objective: To evaluate whether published AUC identify melanomas for which MMS may benefit patients by detecting subclinical spread or confirming clear microscopic margins before flap or graft reconstruction.
Materials and methods: Retrospective cohort study of 591 melanomas in 556 patients evaluating the correlation between current AUC (anatomic location, recurrent status, and tumor stage) and subclinical spread or reconstruction with a flap or graft.
Results: Anatomic location on the head, neck, genitalia, hands, feet, or pretibial leg was associated with a significantly higher frequency of subclinical spread (odds ratio (OR) 1.89, p = .0280) and flap or graft reconstruction (OR 10.3, p = .0001). Compared with primary lesions, recurrent melanomas had a higher frequency of subclinical spread (OR 1.78, p = .0104) and reconstruction with a flap or graft (OR 1.67, p = .0217). The frequencies of subclinical spread and flap or graft reconstruction did not differ between in situ and invasive melanomas.
Conclusion: Anatomic location and recurrent status are useful criteria to identify melanomas that may benefit from MMS. Tumor stage is not a useful criterion, as MMS has similar benefits for subsets of both invasive and in situ melanomas.