Alcoholic liver disease encompasses the progressive stages of liver dysfunction that culminates in alcoholic cirrhosis (AC) and in severe cases alcoholic hepatitis (AH). Currently, prognostic scores have limited specificity and sensitivity. Plasma keratin-18 (K18) levels are elevated during liver disease and may be biomarkers of outcome. The objective of this study was to determine if total K18 (M65) or caspase-cleaved K18 (M30) levels were different between AC and AH patients. M65 and M30 levels were measured in the plasma of consented healthy controls and patients with AC and AH. Cell death was assessed by TUNEL staining and caspase activity. M65 and M30 values were significantly higher in AC patients compared to healthy controls and further increased in AH patients. The M65 values and the M30/M65 ratios of nonsurviving AH patients were significantly elevated above their surviving counterparts and healthy controls. Statistical analysis indicated that M30/M65 ratios outperformed current indices for accurately distinguishing the prognosis of AH patients. These scores occurred with minimal increase in plasma cell death markers such as ALT and AST. Serum caspase activity, TUNEL staining, and M30 immunohistochemistry in biopsies indicated that serum and tissue values may not correlate well with overall cell death. In conclusion, both M65 and M30 differentiate AH from AC patients, and M65 values and the M30/M65 ratio are capable of predicting early stage mortality; however, they may not accurately reflect pure hepatocyte cell death in these populations, as they do not strongly correlate with traditional cell death markers.