Flow and clog in a silo with oscillating exit

Phys Rev E. 2017 Sep;96(3-1):032906. doi: 10.1103/PhysRevE.96.032906. Epub 2017 Sep 14.

Abstract

When grains flow out of a silo, flow rate W increases with exit size D. If D is too small, an arch may form and the flow may be blocked at the exit. To recover from clogging, the arch has to be destroyed. Here we construct a two-dimensional silo with movable exit and study the effects of exit oscillation (with amplitude A and frequency f) on flow rate, clogging, and unclogging of grains through the exit. We find that, if exit oscillates, W remains finite even when D (measured in unit of grain diameter) is only slightly larger than one. Surprisingly, while W increases with oscillation strength Γ≡4π^{2}Af^{2} as expected at small D, W decreases with Γ when D≥5 due to induced random motion of the grains at the exit. When D is small and oscillation speed v≡2πAf is slow, temporary clogging events cause the grains to flow intermittently. In this regime, W depends only on v-a feature consistent to a simple arch breaking mechanism, and the phase boundary of intermittent flow in the D-v plane is consistent to either a power law: D∝v^{-7} or an exponential form: D∝e^{-D/0.55}. Furthermore, the flow time statistic is Poissonian whereas the recovery time statistic follows a power-law distribution.