An analysis of the setting of the acute reference dose (ARfD) for pesticides in Europe

To protect human health, acute reference values have been established for pesticides which have the potential to cause a toxic effect after acute human exposure. These values are used to identify exposure levels below which there is no appreciable risk. Comprehensive reference documents, including OECD criteria, are available to aid identification of relevant toxicological endpoints. Within Europe, there is a concern that the identification process is inconsistent and unnecessarily conservative such that safe products with no established human health risk are being restricted. For this reason, the basis for the setting of an acute reference dose (ARfD) has been investigated for 130 pesticides to better understand how the toxicological endpoints are selected. The investigation has shown that most ARfDs are derived from repeat dose studies and that there is an over-representation of prenatal developmental toxicity studies. There is clear evidence that ARfDs derived from rabbit developmental toxicity studies are set over conservatively with regard to acute maternal effects and often inappropriately. To facilitate an improved system, refinements to the existing process are recommended, the use of maternal data in the rabbit as the basis for deriving an ARfD is critically evaluated and a new, more pragmatic approach to ARfD derivation is proposed.