Only a few cases of syndrome of inappropriate antidiuretic hormone secretion (SIADH) in the setting of amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) have been described in the literature. We present the case of an 81-year-old male who developed severe hyponatremia following elective total hip replacement. His past medical history included prostate cancer, which was under surveillance, and ischemic heart disease. He reported recent weight loss, worsening shortness of breath, and lethargy. SIADH was diagnosed on the basis of hyponatremia, elevated urinary sodium, and decreased serum osmolality, presumed secondary to surgery. Investigations revealed no occult malignancy and no other cause for hyponatremia. He was discharged when sodium levels had normalized, however, he then had several further admissions for hyponatremia, general fatigue, and breathlessness. His condition continued to decline, and he developed dysphagia, weakness, and tongue fasciculations. Neurological examination showed globally decreased power, increased tone, and fasciculations. MRI of the brain was normal. He did not respond to neostigmine treatment, and a presumed diagnosis of motor neuron disease was made. The patient passed away shortly after this, and a post-mortem confirmed the diagnosis of ALS. Drug, post-operative, and cancer-related causes were precluded by the timing of onset of hyponatremia. We present this case and an analysis of previously published cases alongside a discussion on the potential causative mechanisms.