Saxitoxin (STX) is the archetype of a large family (>50) of architecturally distinct, bisguanidinium natural products. Among this collection of isolates, two members, 11-saxitoxinethanoic acid (11-SEA) and zetekitoxin AB (ZTX), are unique, bearing carbon substitution at C11. A desire to efficiently access these compounds has motivated the development of new tactical approaches to a late-stage C11-ketone intermediate 26, designed to enable C-C bond formation using any one of a number of possible reaction technologies. Highlights of the synthesis of 26 include a metal-free, silylpyrrole oxidative dearomatization reaction and a vinylsilane epoxidation-rearrangement cascade to generate the requisite ketone. Nucleophilic addition to 26 makes possible the preparation of unnatural C11-substituted STXs. Olefination of this ketone is also demonstrated and, when followed by a redox-neutral isomerization reaction, affords 11-SEA.