Five-year cause-specific survival after meningioma surgery. A nationwide population-based study

Background: Survival after meningioma surgery is often reported with inadequate allowance for competing causes of death.

Methods: We processed the French administrative medical database (Système National des Données de Santé: SNDS), to retrieve appropriate cases of surgically treated meningioma. Cause-specific survival in meningioma-related death was analyzed with the Fine & Gray (F&G) and cause-specific (CS) Cox models to identify associated factors.

Results: Five-year cumulative incidence was 2.85% for meningioma-related death and 6.3% for unrelated death (P<0.001). In the adjusted F&G and cause-specific Cox regression models for meningioma-related death, gender, age at surgery, co-morbidities, neurofibromatosis type 2, tumor insertion, tumor grade, cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) shunt insertion, preoperative embolization and need for redo surgery for recurrence emerged as independent prognostic factors of cause-specific survival (CSS) in meningioma-related death.

Conclusion: At 5 years, the risk of meningioma-unrelated death was 2.21-fold greater than the risk of dying from the meningioma disease. Five-year CSS after meningioma surgery was greater in younger adults with benign spinal meningioma with low comorbidity. Those with malignant cranial tumor requiring preoperative embolization or CSF shunting for associated hydrocephalus and with severely degraded overall health status showed a significantly increased risk of meningioma-related death. Redo surgery for recurrence failed to improve the risk of meningioma-related death. We recommend the use of net survival methods such as CSS in meningioma studies where unrelated mortality is predominant, as this approach results in more accurate estimates of disease risk and associated predictors.