Introduction: We describe the establishment of the Michigan Urological Surgery Improvement Collaborative-Kidney mass: Identifying and Defining Necessary Evaluation and therapY (MUSIC-KIDNEY) to improve the quality of care that patients in Michigan receive for localized, 7 cm or smaller (T1) renal masses.
Methods: The MUSIC-KIDNEY collaborative is comprised of 45 urologists from 8 group practices. From June 2017 to November 2018 surgeons collected data for 821 patients with newly diagnosed T1 renal masses. Goals are to reduce the overall burden of treatment for T1 renal masses specifically by avoiding treatment when a noninterventional approach is appropriate, reducing the treatment of benign renal masses, preventing radical nephrectomy when a kidney sparing approach is appropriate, and decreasing length of hospitalization and readmission rates.
Results: Median age at diagnosis was 66 years, 56.8% of patients were male and 83.8% were Caucasian. The patient populations differed across practice sites for age (p <0.001), tumor size (p=0.002), race (p <0.001), Charlson comorbidity index and insurance type (p <0.001). Tumor complexity was infrequently reported (35.1%). Initial management included surveillance/repeat imaging (45.1%), biopsy (15.4%), intervention (39.1%) and second opinion (0.6%). No treatment at initial presentation (0% to 74.5%) and nephron sparing treatment (0% to 100%) varied significantly among practices (p <0.001). Of 133 patients with T1 renal masses who underwent radical nephrectomy (39.8%) 53 had tumors smaller than 4 cm and/or surgical findings without malignancy. Readmission or emergency department visit within 30 days after renal surgery occurred in 7.6%.
Conclusions: Initial findings of MUSIC-KIDNEY indicate practice level variation and several quality improvement opportunities. Focusing on these goals may optimize practice patterns and surgical outcomes across Michigan.
Keywords: carcinoma; health information management; quality of health care; renal cell.