The bacillamides are a class of indole alkaloids produced by the Bacillus genus that possess significant antialgal activity. Incorporation of fluorine into the bacillamides was carried out using a precursor-directed biosynthesis approach, with 4-, 5-, and 6-fluorotryptophan added to growing cultures of Bacillus atrophaeus IMG-11. This yielded the corresponding fluorinated analogues of bacillamides A and C, in addition to new derivatives of the related metabolite N-acetyltryptamine, thus demonstrating a degree of plasticity in the bacillamide biosynthetic pathway. The bacillamide derivatives were tested for activity against bloom-forming algae, which revealed that fluorination could improve the antialgal activity of these compounds in a site-specific manner, with fluorination at the 6-position consistently resulting in improved activity.