Enzymes catalyzing peptide macrocyclization are important biochemical tools in drug discovery. The three-residue cyclophane-forming enzymes (3-CyFEs) are an emerging family of post-translational modifying enzymes that catalyze the formation of three-residue peptide cyclophanes. In this report, we introduce three additional 3-CyFEs, including ChlB, WnsB, and FnnB, that catalyze cyclophane formation on Tyr, Trp, and Phe, respectively. To understand the promiscuity of these enzymes and those previously reported (MscB, HaaB, and YxdB), we tested single amino acid substitutions at the three-residue motif of modification (Ω1X2X3, Ω1 = aromatic). Collectively, we observe that substrate promiscuity is observed at the Ω1 and X2 positions, but a greater specificity is observed for the X3 residue. Two nonnative cyclophane products were characterized showing a Phe-C3 to Arg-Cβ and His-C2 to Pro-Cβ cross-links, respectively. We also tested the leader dependence of selected 3-CyFEs and show that a predicted helix region is important for cyclophane formation. These results demonstrate the biocatalytic potential of these maturases and allow rational design of substrates to obtain a diverse array of genetically encoded 3-residue cyclophanes.