In healthy adults different language abilities-sentence processing versus emotional prosody-are supported by the left (LH) versus the right hemisphere (RH), respectively. However, after LH stroke in infancy, RH regions support both abilities with normal outcomes. We investigated how these abilities co-exist in RH regions after LH perinatal stroke by evaluating the overlap in the activation between two fMRI tasks that probed auditory sentence processing and emotional prosody processing. We compared the overlap for these two functions in the RH of individuals with perinatal stroke with the symmetry of these functions in the LH and RH of their healthy siblings. We found less activation overlap in the RH of individuals with LH perinatal stroke than would be expected if both functions retained their typical spatial layout, suggesting that their spatial segregation may be an important feature of a functioning language system.