Do extremely large goiters carry a higher risk of malignancy or complications? A case control study

Introduction: The definition of thyroid goiter remains ambiguous, yet size may impact both malignancy rate and surgical complications' rate.

Methods: All patients with thyroid goiter who underwent thyroidectomy between 1/2015-1/2023 were included. Goiter was defined as lobe ≥4 cm. For analysis purpose, goiters measuring 4-8 cm and ≥8 cm were defined as large and extremely large goiters, respectively. For malignancy definition, tumor<1 cm in their largest diameter were excluded from study. Collected data included demographics, cytology, histology and postoperative complication.

Results: 144 goiters from 111 patients were included. The most common indication for surgery was symptoms (55 %). Compared with large goiter, extremely large goiters demonstrated a trend for tracheal narrowing on pre-operative CT findings (23 % vs. 45 %, p = 0.07 respectively). Overall differentiated thyroid carcinoma (DTC) rate was 17 % (25/144) without statistical difference between groups (p = 0.89). Within goiters with pre-operative benign cytology, the DTC rate was 17 % (7/43). Follicular variant of papillary thyroid cancer was the most common type for both groups. Nodular hyperplasia was significantly associated with extremely large goiters (53 % vs. 73 %, p = 0.03). No significant difference was found in transient hypocalcemia (48 % [15/31] vs. 41 % [5/12], p = 0.6) and other complications' rate between extremely large goiters and the control group.

Conclusion: When discussing management options for patients with goiters, the size of the goiter should not regarded as a higher risk for complications or malignancy, yet the relatively high malignancy rate found should be taken under consideration for resection.