Value-based comparison of ambulatory children with respiratory diseases in an emergency department and a walk-in clinic: a retrospective cohort study in Québec, Canada

BMJ Open. 2024 Apr 25;14(4):e078566. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2023-078566.

Abstract

Objective: To compare health outcomes and costs given in the emergency department (ED) and walk-in clinics for ambulatory children presenting with acute respiratory diseases.

Design: A retrospective cohort study.

Setting: This study was conducted from April 2016 to March 2017 in one ED and one walk-in clinic. The ED is a paediatric tertiary care centre, and the clinic has access to lab tests and X-rays.

Participants: Inclusion criteria were children: (1) aged from 2 to 17 years old and (2) discharged home with a diagnosis of upper respiratory tract infection (URTI), pneumonia or acute asthma.

Main outcome measures: The primary outcome measure was the proportion of patients returning to any ED or clinic within 3 and 7 days of the index visit. The secondary outcome measures were the mean cost of care estimated using time-driven activity-based costing and the incidence of antibiotic prescription for URTI patients.

Results: We included 532 children seen in the ED and 201 seen in the walk-in clinic. The incidence of return visits at 3 and 7 days was 20.7% and 27.3% in the ED vs 6.5% and 11.4% in the clinic (adjusted relative risk at 3 days (aRR) (95% CI) 3.17 (1.77 to 5.66) and aRR at 7 days 2.24 (1.46 to 3.44)). The mean cost (95% CI) of care (CAD) at the index visit was $C96.68 (92.62 to 100.74) in the ED vs $C48.82 (45.47 to 52.16) in the clinic (mean difference (95% CI): 46.15 (41.29 to 51.02)). Antibiotic prescription for URTI was less common in the ED than in the clinic (1.5% vs 16.4%; aRR 0.10 (95% CI 0.03 to 0.32)).

Conclusions: The incidence of return visits and cost of care were significantly higher in the ED, while antibiotic use for URTI was more frequent in the walk-in clinic. These data may help determine which setting offers the highest value to ambulatory children with acute respiratory conditions.

Keywords: paediatric A&E and ambulatory care; quality in health care; respiratory infections.

Publication types

  • Comparative Study
  • Research Support, Non-U.S. Gov't

MeSH terms

  • Adolescent
  • Ambulatory Care / economics
  • Ambulatory Care / statistics & numerical data
  • Ambulatory Care Facilities* / economics
  • Ambulatory Care Facilities* / statistics & numerical data
  • Anti-Bacterial Agents / economics
  • Anti-Bacterial Agents / therapeutic use
  • Asthma / drug therapy
  • Asthma / economics
  • Child
  • Child, Preschool
  • Emergency Service, Hospital* / statistics & numerical data
  • Female
  • Health Care Costs / statistics & numerical data
  • Humans
  • Male
  • Pneumonia / drug therapy
  • Pneumonia / economics
  • Pneumonia / epidemiology
  • Quebec
  • Respiratory Tract Infections* / drug therapy
  • Respiratory Tract Infections* / economics
  • Respiratory Tract Infections* / epidemiology
  • Retrospective Studies

Substances

  • Anti-Bacterial Agents