The M4 muscarinic acetylcholine receptor (mAChR) is a biological target for neurocognitive disorders. Compound 1 is an ago-PAM for the M4 mAChR. Herein, we report the design, synthesis, and evaluation of novel putative M4 mAChR PAMs based on 1. These analogs were screened and then fully characterized in two functional assays (GoB protein activation and CAMYEL activation) to quantify their allosteric and ago-PAM properties against ACh. A selection of 7 M4 PAMs were assessed for their ability to modulate ACh-mediated β-arrestin recruitment and revealed 4 distinct clusters of M4 PAM activity: (1) analogs similar to 1 (24d), (2) analogs demonstrating only allosteric agonism (23d), (3) analogs with increased allosteric properties in CAMYEL activation (23b/23f and 24a/24b), and (4) analogs with a biased modulatory effect toward β-arrestin recruitment (23i). These novel M4 chemical tools disclose discrete molecular determinants, allowing further interrogation of the therapeutic roles of cAMP and β-arrestin pathways in neurocognitive disorders.