Iatrogenic Intraoperative Fracture in Patients With Osteogenesis Imperfecta

Background: Osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) is a genetic defect in collagen type I, phenotypically characterized by bony fragility and a propensity to high rates of childhood fracture. Fragility fractures in patients with OI have been reported with routine hospital care. In addition, there is a nonzero rate of iatrogenic fracture during orthopaedic surgery directly related to the technical steps of the procedure itself. The rate of this latter has never been explicitly investigated.

Methods: A review of all patients at a single OI referral center was conducted, including all patients with a diagnosis of OI seen between 2013 and 2023, inclusive. All patients who underwent orthopaedic surgery of any kind were reviewed, and clinical and radiographic details of all procedures were extracted. Among the details examined were the OI subtype, surgery details, any implants used, intraoperative and hospital stay complications, modified Clavien-Dindo classification of complications, and ultimate outcome.

Results: Eleven of 60 patients experienced an unplanned, iatrogenic intraoperative fracture during orthopaedic surgery (11/60 = 18.3%). This comprised 15 fractures among 356 total orthopaedic surgical episodes (15/356 = 4.2%). All but one fracture occurred on the operative long bone segment, all were a direct result of surgical steps, and 11 of 15 fractures occurred in the femur. Most fractures were secondary to the removal, insertion, or exchange of intramedullary implants in the lower extremity (11 of 15 fractures), most often the femur. Thirteen of 15 injuries were classified as modified Clavien-Dindo II or III, requiring modification of postop rehabilitation, additional treatments, or surgical intervention (87%). Overall, iatrogenic fracture was the most common intraoperative complication experienced in the cohort.

Conclusions: Iatrogenic fracture during orthopaedic surgery for patients with OI is not uncommon. A sizeable minority of patients with OI undergoing orthopaedic surgery will experience unplanned fractures, most commonly in the femur, and care is altered in most instances. The risk of intraoperative fracture can be discussed with families of children with OI as part of informed consent and shared decision-making.

Level of evidence: Level IV-retrospective cohort series.