Elective complex ventral hernia repair in contaminated fields: A propensity score-matched analysis of long-term quality of life and outcomes between different prostheses

Background: Randomized studies have endorsed nonabsorbable prosthetics for contaminated ventral hernia surgery, yet the broader applicability and impact on patient-reported outcomes are still questioned. Here, we evaluated the long-term outcomes of elective contaminated ventral hernia repairs (based on Centers of Disease Control and Prevention [CDC] wound classification) using real-world data from a multicenter US cohort, focusing on quality of life and postoperative pain.

Methods: The Abdominal Core Health Quality Collaborative database was queried for patients undergoing elective contaminated (CDC class II-IV) ventral hernia repair (2013-2023). After propensity matching, we compared long-term differences in patient-reported quality of life and pain scores (by HerQLes and PROMIS questionnaires) among those who underwent repair with nonabsorbable, absorbable synthetic, and biologic mesh.

Results: A total of 1,073 patients were included, of whom 920 (86%), 56 (5%), and 97 (9%) underwent repair with nonabsorbable, absorbable synthetic, and biologic mesh, respectively. Among them, the median age was 62 years (interquartile range [IQR] 53-70), and 523 (49%) were male. The median length and width of the defect were 20 cm (IQR 12-25) and 13 cm (IQR 8-16), respectively. A transversus abdominis release was performed in 716 patients (67% of all cases). In most cases, the mesh was positioned in the retro-rectus (85%) and/or the preperitoneal space (45%). Before and after propensity matching (n = 185), the change from baseline in HerQLes and PROMIS scores at 6 months and at 1, 3, 5, and 6 years was comparable between different types of mesh. Lastly, there were no differences in readmission, surgical site infection, or surgical site occurrence at 30 days. Recurrence at 1 year was also comparable among groups.

Conclusion: In the long term, there were no differences in quality of life or pain scores with nonabsorbable, absorbable synthetic, or biologic mesh for elective ventral hernia repair in contaminated fields.