A Comprehensive Analysis of Class I Medical Device Recalls: Unveiling Patterns, Causes and Global Impacts

Cureus. 2024 Aug 22;16(8):e67542. doi: 10.7759/cureus.67542. eCollection 2024 Aug.

Abstract

In the landscape of medical device regulation, Class I recalls serve as pivotal indicators of potential risks, necessitating comprehensive analysis to unveil underlying patterns and causal factors. This research offers a detailed examination of Class 1 recalls, focusing on the critical aspects of device classification, review panel involvement, and the geographic distribution of recalling companies. Utilizing a robust dataset spanning multiple jurisdictions and device categories, this study reveals recurring trends in recall occurrences, providing insights into the regulatory mechanisms governing device safety assessments. Furthermore, it investigates the role of review panels in evaluating device safety and effectiveness, shedding light on their significance in the recall process. Moreover, the analysis explores the countries of origin of companies initiating recalls, offering insights into the global impact of regulatory actions on medical device manufacturers. By understanding the drivers behind recall decisions and their implications on a regional scale, regulatory authorities, and healthcare stakeholders can implement targeted measures to enhance patient safety and strengthen post-market surveillance practices.

Keywords: device; enforcement actions; recall; safety; usfda.