Silane and acid etch cross contamination of dentin and composite reduced µ-tensile bond strength

Objectives: To investigate whether acid etch contamination of silane-treated composite influenced repair bond strength and whether silane contamination on dentin influenced composite bond strength to dentin.

Materials and methods: Forty composite blocks stored in water for 4 weeks were divided into four groups. Specimens in groups 1-3 were coated with Bis-Silane and contaminated with acid etch + water spray (group 1) or water spray (group 2). Group 3 was not contaminated. Group 4 was untreated. The occlusal third of 60 third molars was cut off, ground flat, and divided into three groups. After etching, the surfaces in groups A and B were contaminated with Bis-silane. The contaminated surfaces in group A were re-etched.Each composite repair group and composite-dentin group was divided into two subgroups receiving Adper Scotchbond 1 XT or Clearfil SE Bond 2 adhesives followed by a composite build up. After ageing for 3 months, specimens were sectioned into 1.1 mm × 1.1 mm rods for tensile testing and strength calculated at fracture. The fracture was examined using microscope.

Results: Bis-Silane surface treatment increased the repair bond strength. Contamination with acid reduced the strength of the repair bond. Similar results were obtained for both adhesives. Tooth surface contamination with silane reduced the bond strength between dentin and composite. Additional acid etching or water spray on silane contaminated dentin did not influence the weakened bond strength. Most fractures were adhesive type.

Conclusions: Silane contamination on etched dentin and acid etch contamination on silanized composite surfaces significantly reduced tensile bond strength.