Noninvasive Modulation of the Subcallosal Cingulate and Depression With Focused Ultrasonic Waves

Background: Severe forms of depression have been linked to excessive subcallosal cingulate cortex (SCC) activity. Stimulation of the SCC with surgically implanted electrodes can alleviate depression, but current noninvasive techniques cannot directly and selectively modulate deep targets. We developed a new noninvasive neuromodulation approach that can deliver low-intensity focused ultrasonic waves to the SCC.

Methods: Twenty-two individuals with treatment-resistant depression participated in a randomized, double-blind, sham-controlled study. Ultrasonic stimulation was delivered to the bilateral SCC during concurrent functional magnetic resonance imaging to quantify target engagement. Mood state was measured with the Sadness subscale of the Positive and Negative Affect Schedule before and after 40 minutes of real or sham SCC stimulation. Change in depression severity was measured with the 6-item Hamilton Depression Rating Scale at 24 hours and 7 days.

Results: Functional magnetic resonance imaging demonstrated a target-specific decrease in SCC activity during stimulation (p = .028, n = 16). In 7 of 16 participants, SCC neuromodulation was detectable at the individual participant level with a single 10-minute scan (p < .05, small-volume correction). Mood and depression scores improved more with real than with sham stimulation. In the per-protocol sample (n = 19), real stimulation was superior to sham for 6-item Hamilton Depression Rating Scale scores at 24 hours and for Sadness scores (both p < .05, d > 1). Nonsignificant trends were found in the intent-to-treat sample.

Conclusions: This small pilot study indicates that ultrasonic stimulation modulates SCC activity and can rapidly reduce depressive symptoms. The capability to noninvasively and selectively target deep brain areas creates new possibilities for the future development of circuit-directed therapeutics and for the analysis of deep-brain circuit function in humans.