Evaluation of the nonstapling bullectomy by manual suturing for young men with primary spontaneous pneumothorax

Background: Currently, surgery for primary spontaneous pneumothorax (PSP) is performed by bullectomy using a stapler with complete video-assisted thoracic surgery (cVATS). However, the postoperative recurrence rate (RR) of PSP is high in young men. The factors of postoperative PSP recurrence are the formation of postoperative bulla neogenesis (POBN) around the staple line, pleural injury caused by forceps for VATS, and bulla overlooked with a thoracoscope. We attempted nonstapling bullectomy with one-port-one-window (1p-1w) by using hybrid VATS (hVATS) to reduce postoperative RR. This study aimed to evaluate nonstapling bullectomy by manual suturing for young male patients with PSP compared with bullectomy by cVATS.

Methods: From January 2012 to December 2022, we retrospectively reviewed the medical records of 259 male patients aged ≤25 years who underwent initial surgery for PSP and compared them between two groups, with staple use (S+) or by manual suturing without staple use (S-). RR, operative time, blood loss, and postoperative hospitalization period were examined in both groups.

Results: The median operative time was 81 and 63 min in the S- and S+ groups, respectively (P<0.001), with the S- group tending to be statistically significantly longer. The mean intraoperative blood loss was 1.61 and 2.11 mL in the S- and S+ groups, respectively (P=0.003). The median postoperative hospitalization period was 4 days in both groups (P=0.32). Recurrences occurred in 8 (7.1%) and 14 patients (12.2%) in the S- and S+ groups, respectively [odds ratio (OR) =0.55; 95% confidence interval (CI): 0.22-1.37; P=0.19]. In patients aged <20 years, 5 (6.6%) and 10 (14.1%) patients had a recurrence in the S- and S+ groups, respectively (OR =0.42; 95% CI: 0.13-1.32; P=0.13).

Conclusions: Compared with stapling bullectomy, nonstapling bullectomy with small thoracotomy for young male patients with PSP had lesser RR. This procedure is beneficial in reducing postoperative recurrence and is one of the surgical choices for young male patients with PSP.