Validation of Inter-Reader Agreement/Consistency for Quantification of Ellipsoid Zone Integrity and Sub-RPE Compartmental Features Across Retinal Diseases

Background: An unmet need exists when clinically assessing retinal and layer-based features of retinal diseases. Therefore, quantification of retinal-layer-thicknesses/fluid volumes using deep-learning-augmented platforms to reproduce human-obtained clinical measurements is needed.

Methods: In this analysis, 210 spectral-domain optical coherence tomography (SD-OCT) scans (30 without pathology, 60 dry age-related macular degeneration [AMD], 60 wet AMD, and 60 diabetic macular edema [total 23,625 B-scans]) were included. A fully automated segmentation platform segmented four retinal layers for compartmental assessment (internal limiting membrane, ellipsoid zone [EZ], retinal pigment epithelium [RPE], and Bruch's membrane). Two certified OCT readers independently completed manual segmentation and B-scan level validation of automated segmentation, with segmentation correction when needed (semi-automated). Certified reader metrics were compared to gold standard metrics using intraclass correlation coefficients (ICCs) to assess overall agreement. Across different diseases, several metrics generated from automated segmentations approached or matched human readers performance.

Results: Absolute ICCs for retinal mean thickness measurements showed excellent agreement (range 0.980-0.999) across four cohorts. EZ-RPE thickness values and sub-RPE compartment ICCs demonstrated excellent agreement (ranges of 0.953-0.987 and 0.944-0.997, respectively) for full dataset, dry-AMD, and wet-AMD cohorts.

Conclusions: Analyses demonstrated high reliability and consistency of segmentation of outer retinal compartmental features using a completely human/manual approach or a semi-automated approach to segmentation. These results support the critical role that measuring features, such as photoreceptor preservation through EZ integrity, in future clinical trials may optimize clinical care.