Evaluating the Relationship Between Surface and Intramuscular-Based Electromyography Signals: Implications of Subcutaneous Fat Thickness

Intramuscular (iEMG) and surface electromyographic (sEMG) signals have been compared previously using predictive regression equations, finite element modeling, and correlation and cross-correlation analyses. Although subcutaneous fat thickness (SCFT) has been identified as a primary source of sEMG signal amplitude attenuation and low-pass filter equivalence, few studies have explored the potential effect of SCFT on sEMG and iEMG signal characteristics. The purpose of this study was to investigate the relationship between normalized submaximal iEMG and sEMG signal amplitudes collected from 4 muscles (rectus femoris, vastus lateralis, infraspinatus, and erector spinae) and determine whether SCFT explains more variance in this relationship. The effect of sex was also explored. Linear regression models demonstrated that the relationship between sEMG and iEMG was highly variable across the muscles examined (adjusted coefficient of determination [Adj R2] = .02-.74). SCFT improved the model fit for vastus lateralis, although this relationship only emerged with the inclusion of sex as a covariate. Thus, this research suggests that SCFT is not a prominent factor affecting the linearity between sEMG and iEMG. Researchers should investigate other parameters that may affect the linearity between sEMG and iEMG signals.