LDAPrototype: a model selection algorithm to improve reliability of latent Dirichlet allocation

Latent Dirichlet allocation (LDA) is a popular method for analyzing large text corpora, but it suffers from instability due to its reliance on random initialization. This results in different outcomes for replicated runs, hindering reproducibility. To address this, we introduce LDAPrototype, a new approach for selecting the most representative LDA run from multiple replications on the same dataset. LDAPrototype enhances the reliability of LDA conclusions by ensuring greater similarity between replications compared to traditional LDA runs or models chosen based on perplexity or NPMI. A key feature of LDAPrototype is its use of a novel model similarity measure called S-CLOP (Similarity of multiple sets by Clustering with LOcal Pruning). It is based on topic similarities, for which we compare the usage of measures like the thresholded Jaccard coefficient, cosine similarity, Jensen-Shannon divergence, and rank-biased overlap. The effectiveness of LDAPrototype is demonstrated through its application to six real datasets, including newspaper articles and tweets. The results show improved reproducibility and reliability in topic modeling outcomes. LDAPrototype's approach is noteworthy for its practical applicability, comprehensibility, ease of implementation, and computational efficiency. Furthermore, the algorithm's concept can be generalized to other topic modeling procedures that characterize topics through word distributions, making it a versatile tool in text data analysis.