Enhanced Blastocystis subtyping from stool samples using semi-nested barcode PCR: validation with an NGS-based approach

Biotechniques. 2024 Dec 27:1-11. doi: 10.1080/07366205.2024.2442835. Online ahead of print.

Abstract

In 2006, a PCR method was introduced to subtype Blastocystis by Sanger sequencing of an ≈610 bp amplicon of the 18S rRNA gene. This method, known as barcoding-PCR, has become widespread, although the primer pair used can amplify non-Blastocystis sequences, which can result in false positives. Barcoding-PCR is most effective with DNA extracted from Blastocystis cultures, limiting its sensitivity when used directly with stool samples. As a result, barcoding-PCR can sometimes yield negative results for stool samples confirmed as Blastocystis-positive by microscopy. To improve subtyping from stool-derived DNA, we developed a Semi-Nested barcode PCR that amplifies the barcoding region in a second reaction. Our study shows that this Semi-Nested approach outperforms classical barcoding-PCR, detecting Blastocystis more reliably from stool samples with stronger gel signals and no false positives. This was confirmed by near-complete concordance (68/70 samples) with the Santin-PCR coupled to Next-Generation Sequencing (NGS) as reference standard for Blastocystis subtyping. Of particular interest, one amplicon matched the only previous report of ST35, marking this as the second global detection of ST35 and the first in Colombia. Overall, Semi-Nested barcoded PCR offers a more robust and sensitive alternative compared to classical barcoding-PCR for subtyping Blastocystis directly from stool samples.

Keywords: Blastocystis subtyping; ST35; Santin PCR; next-generation sequencing; semi-nested barcode PCR.

Plain language summary

DNA extracted from stool samples identified as Blastocystis-positive by microscopy was analyzed using both classical barcoding-PCR and Semi-Nested barcode PCR for genotyping. Semi-nested barcoding PCR produced more distinct amplicons on gels (83% versus 50%), leading to an evaluation of the potential for false-positive signals due to contamination. Therefore, Semi-Nested barcode PCR products were subjected to Sanger sequencing, and the resulting subtypes were compared with those identified using Santin-PCR combined with NGS (Illumina MiSeq). The results showed 98% concordance, demonstrating that, compared to classical barcoding-PCR, Semi-Nested barcode PCR enhances robustness and sensitivity for the direct analysis of stool samples.