We report five cases in which anorectal stenosis was associated with chronic administration of suppositories containing paracetamol and acetylsalicylic acid. All patients were females taking suppositories for chronic migraine. Patients experienced anal pain, tenesmus, fecal incontinence, and, in two cases, intestinal obstruction. Lesions were characterized by a severe circular narrowing of the distal rectum with superficial ulcerations. Radiographs demonstrated the presence of sinus-tract-like formations in the diseased segment and thickening of the rectal wall. Histologic examination showed signs of chronic inflammation with deep ulcerations associated with obliteration of the lamina propria by a fibromuscular proliferation, as was described in the solitary ulcer syndrome of the rectum. Rectal administration of suppositories was discontinued in all the patients. Two patients were improved by anorectal dilatation, but the remaining three required a left proctocolectomy with subsequent coloanal anastomosis. The use of such suppositories must be restricted.