Purpose: Patellar tendon autografts have been considered by many as the gold standard for intraarticular reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL). Hamstring tendon grafts are being used increasingly, however there are few studies focusing on their mechanical properties. The objectives of the present study are to determine the strength of a semitendinosus graft at various postoperative periods.
Methods: In Part I of the study, a looped semitendinosus graft was used to reconstruct the ACL in five frozen human cadaver knees with a simulated endoscopic technique. The immediate post-operative strength was determined by loading the knees of failure using a mechanical testing system. In Part II the effects of graft maturation and incorporation were considered. A similar graft was used to reconstruct the ACL in twelve ewe sheep. Their knees were harvested and tested at four, eight, and twelve weeks postoperatively.
Results: The mean maximum strength and stiffness of the cadaveric reconstructions were 352 N and 8.18 N/mm, respectively. All failures occurred at the fixation sites. The average strength of the sheep reconstructions was similar at four, eight, and twelve weeks (376 N. 415 N. and 323 N. respectively). The stiffness increased from 21.1 N/mm at four weeks to 46.7 N/mm at eight weeks and then remained the same. The failures occurred primarily by tendon pull-out of the femoral tunnel at four, eight and twelve weeks.
Conclusions: Graft pull-out from the femoral tunnel implies incomplete tendon incorporation during the initial three months post-operatively. Activities which place high loads on the graft should be avoided during this period. Additionally, the mechanical properties of this hamstring graft reconstruction are similar to those reported for patellar tendon grafts in other animal models.