The phenylethanolamines, ifenprodil and CP-101,606, are NMDA receptor antagonists with promising neuroprotective properties. In recombinant NMDA receptors expressed in Xenopus oocytes, we found that these drugs inhibit NMDA receptors through a unique mechanism, making the receptor more sensitive to inhibition by protons, an endogenous negative modulator. These findings support a critical role for the proton sensor in gating the NMDA receptor and point the way to identifying a context-dependent NMDA receptor antagonist that is inactive at physiological pH, but is a potent inhibitor during the acidic conditions that arise during epilepsy, ischemia and brain trauma.