We analyzed the interaction of two kinds of amyloid beta-peptides (A beta), i.e., A beta(1-42) and A beta(1-40), in the kinetics of beta-amyloid fibril (fA beta) formation in vitro, based on a nucleation-dependent polymerization model using fluorescence spectroscopy with thioflavin T. When 25 microM A beta(1-42) was incubated with increasing concentrations of amyloidogenic A beta(1-40), the time to proceed to equilibrium was extended dose-dependently. A similar inhibitory effect was observed when 45 microM A beta(1-40) was incubated with increasing concentrations of A beta(1-42). On the other hand, when 50 microM of nonamyloidogenic A beta(1-40) was incubated with A beta(1-42) at a molar ratio of 10:1 or 5:1, A beta(1-42) initiated fA beta formation from A beta(1-40). The lag time of the reaction shortened in a concentration-dependent manner, with A beta(1-42). We next examined the seeding effect of fA beta formed from A beta(1-42) (fA beta(1-42)) on nonamyloidogenic A beta(1-40). When 50 microM of nonamyloidogenic A beta(1-40) was incubated with 10 or 20 microg/mL (2.2 or 4.4 microM) of fA beta(1-42), the fluorescence showed a sigmoidal increase. The lag time of the reaction was shortened by fA beta(1-42) in a concentration-dependent manner. However, the time to proceed to equilibrium was much longer than when an equal concentration of fA beta formed from A beta(1-40) (fA beta(1-40)) was added to A beta(1-40). The fluorescence increased hyperbolically without a lag phase when 25 microM A beta(1-42) was incubated with 10 or 20 microg/mL (2.3 or 4.6 microM) of fA beta(1-40), and proceeded to equilibrium more rapidly than without fA beta(1-40). An electron microscopic study indicated that the morphology of fA beta formed is governed by the major component of fresh A beta peptides in the reaction mixture, not by the morphology of preexisting fibrils. These results may indicate the central role of A beta(1-42) for fA beta deposition in vivo, among the different coexisting A beta species.