Intracellular immunoglobulin crystal formation within plasma cells is an uncommon finding in multiple myeloma and other lymphoplasmacytic tumors. We present 12 cases of plasmacytic tumors with prominent crystal formation, including myeloma (5 cases), lymphoplasmacytic lymphoma (6 cases), and a nonneoplastic plasma cell proliferation. In all cases, crystal formation was associated with the proliferation of variable numbers of histiocytes containing similar inclusions. These cases showed a variety of appearances, sometimes obscuring the underlying plasma cell tumor and raising the differential diagnosis of a storage disorder, hemophagocytosis, or a mesenchymal lesion. In cases of lymphoplasmacytic lymphoma, patients typically presented with marked paraproteinemia and symptoms of hyperviscosity. Crystal-storing histiocytosis was not associated with other immunoglobulin deposition disorders, including amyloidosis, Mott cell tumors, or kappa-light chain deposition. In our cases and those previously reported, we found an overwhelming association of crystal-storing histiocytosis (CSH) with tumors expressing immunoglobulin kappa light chain with no consistent association with a particular heavy chain. These results suggest that CSH results from the ingestion of crystals produced by plasma cell tumors that either overproduce kappa light chain or express a structurally aberrant molecule. CSH persists in the marrow and other sites throughout the course of the disease and in our series was not highly associated with development of the adult Fanconi syndrome or rapid clinical deterioration.