An investigation of the scope and mechanism of a new synthesis of cyclopentenes from 3,6-dihydro-2H-thiopyrans is described. Alkyl halides substituted with an electron-withdrawing group in the alpha-position were reacted with sodium thiosulfate, yielding the corresponding Bunte salts, which could be transformed to reactive thiocarbonyl compounds by elimination of the elements of bisulfite with mild base treatment. In situ trapping by 1,3-dienes afforded in good yields a variety of 3,6-dihydro-2H-thiopyrans substituted with electron-withdrawing groups at the 2-position. Exposure of these cycloadducts to strong base at low temperature effected a novel ring contraction, affording 2-(methylthio)-3-cyclopentenes after quenching with methyl iodide. The level of diastereoselectivity exhibited during the generation of these cyclopentenes was found to be dependent on the nature of the electron-withdrawing group at the 2-position of the dihydrothiopyran as well as the substitution pattern originally present in the diene component. In some cases, reducing the temperature during the ring contraction resulted in the isolation of good yields of vinyl cyclopropanes of high isomeric purity. With one substrate, highly diastereoselective rearrangement of a vinyl cyclopropane to a cyclopentene was unambiguously demonstrated, suggesting that this might be a key feature of the overall ring contraction mechanism.