Vacuum line kinetics studies have been made of the reaction in nitromethane between benzene and/or toluene, methoxyacetyl chloride (MAC), and AlCl(3) to produce benzyl or xylyl chlorides, CO, and a CH(3)OH(-)AlCl(3) complex. For both arenes, the rate law appears to be R = (k(3)/[AlCl(3)](0)) [AlCl(3)](2)[MAC]. When chloromethyl methyl ether (CMME) is substituted for MAC, a similar rate law is obtained. Both chloromethylation reactions yielded similar, large k(T)()/k(B)() ratios (500-600) and similar product isomer distributions with low meta percentages ( approximately 0.4) which suggest CH(3)OCH(2)(+) or the CH(3)OCH(2)(+)Al(2)Cl(7)(-) ion pair as a common, remarkably selective, electrophile. The kinetics of MAC decomposition to CMME and CO in the presence of AlCl(3) yielded the rate law R = k(2)[AlCl(3)](0)[MAC]. Here AlCl(3) is a catalyst (no CH(3)OH is formed), and thus the rate law is equivalent to the chloromethylation rate law. All three reactions have comparable reactivities, which is consistent with rate-determining production of the electrophile. Kinetics studies of benzene or toluene with SnCl(4) and MAC or CMME in dichloromethane were also completed. With MAC and benzene the rate law is R = k(3)[SnCl(4)](0)[MAC][benzene] and with toluene R = k(2)[SnCl(4)](0)[MAC]. MAC decomposition, again followed by CO production, was unaffected by the presence of either aromatic and obeyed the rate law R = k(2)' [SnCl(4)](0)[MAC] where k(2) approximately k(2)'. Chloromethylation with CMME followed the rate law R = k(3)[SnCl(4)](0)[CMME][arene] for benzene and toluene and produced a k(T)()/k(B)() ratio and product isomer distributions very similar to those determined with AlCl(3) in nitromethane, further supporting a common electrophile. Low-temperature (13)C and (119)Sn FT-NMR and Raman spectroscopic studies suggest the existence of a weak 1:1 adduct between MAC and SnCl(4) of the type RCXO --> SnCl(4), with electron donation to the metal through carboxy oxygen. Finally, an explanation is provided for the range of chloromethylation k(T)()/k(B)() values and product isomer percentages published in the literature.