The purpose of this study was to develop two instruments for the evaluation of positive and negative appraisal of care among family caregivers of elderly Japanese care recipients within the framework of caregiver adaptation. The positive appraisal of care instrument (PAC) includes domains of relationship satisfaction, role confidence, consequential gain, and normative fulfillment. The negative appraisal of care instrument (NAC) includes domains of role exhaustion, isolation, relationship difficulty, and symptom management difficulty. The PAC and NAC are self-administered questionnaires and were developed from data collected from 337 family caregivers of relatives aged 65 years and over who were using visiting nursing services from 21 organizations in multiple areas of Japan. Out of 87 items, 21 PAC items and 14 NAC items were selected based on content and construct validity and internal consistency examination. Results show evidence of validity and reliability for the PAC and NAC, although some NAC domains may benefit from further refinement. The PAC and NAC will be useful research tools for examining elder caregiving experience and evaluating nursing care for elders.